Christa Pike survived Tennessee’s attempt to execute her by lethal injection. Now, she’s fighting the state again, but this time over what happened after she returned to prison.
Pike, the only woman on Tennessee’s death row, has been granted a new federal court hearing after accusing the prison of placing her back in solitary confinement following her botched execution in September.
Judge Waverly D. Crenshaw Jr. has scheduled oral arguments for Dec. 1, 2026, at 3:30 p.m. in Nashville to address an emergency motion filed by Pike’s attorneys. They are pushing to enforce a 2024 settlement agreement that previously ended her almost 30 years in solitary confinement.
The hearing comes two months after Pike shockingly survived Tennessee’s failed attempt to execute her by lethal injection on Sept. 30. An Oct. 30 court filing reiterates that executioners made multiple unsuccessful attempts to establish an IV line before giving her two doses of pentobarbital. Pike survived but suffered severe injuries per her attorneys. She spent several days on a ventilator and more than a week in intensive care before being discharged from the hospital on Oct. 9.
Since returning to the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center in Nashville, Pike has been confined to the prison infirmary. Her attorneys allege she has been isolated from other inmates and denied opportunities to work, eat meals or participate in activities with the other inmates. Her declaration also includes statements such as, “I have a roach-infested shower that I had to clean on my own, which puts me at a high risk of infection and further injury,” and “I have difficulty using my arms and hands, am experiencing debilitating pain, and have substantial wounds on both arms that are in the healing process. I am currently undergoing wound care, treatment for nerve pain, remote physical therapy, and other treatment for the injuries that the State caused.”
In their emergency motion, Pike’s attorneys argue that the isolation violates a September 2024 agreement that guaranteed her supervised social interaction, recreation, religious services and work.
The agreement settled a federal lawsuit Pike filed in 2022 over how she was being treated in prison. As part of the deal, the judge kept the power to step in if either side failed to follow the agreement.
In an Oct. 14 email included in the court filings, attorney Brian Roark said he was concerned about Pike’s housing arrangements and asked that she be placed in a medical housing unit where she could receive treatment without being totally isolated. Roark also cited concerns about Pike’s mental health, including her limited contact with nurses and staff members, and requested access to immediate and long-term mental health services following the failed execution.
The attorney also asked the prison to allow Pike to repurchase clothing and other personal items she had given away before her scheduled execution, noting that weekly spending limits were preventing her from replacing her items. He also questioned why Pike’s spiritual adviser was reportedly restricted to visits on Monday evenings and weekends rather than the previous visitation schedule.
Credit: Tennessee Middle District CourtTennessee has opposed the emergency motion. The state maintains that Pike’s housing restrictions are related to her medical condition and security classification over an attempt to violate the settlement.
As Los Angeles Magazine previously reported, Pike’s attorneys are also fighting to preserve evidence from the failed execution, including IV equipment, remaining execution drugs and surveillance footage. In a separate proceeding, Tennessee wants to prevent Pike’s attorneys from inspecting or testing the remaining pentobarbital, arguing that doing so could reveal the identity of the state’s confidential drug supplier.
Pike was sentenced to death for the brutak 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer.
The post After Surviving Lethal Injection, Christa Pike Says Tennessee Is Punishing Her Again appeared first on LAmag.